Available now
Tottenville apartments
Neighborhood guide
Living in Tottenville.
Tottenville is one of Staten Island's most sought-after neighborhoods. The southernmost tip — quiet, leafy, waterfront. Renters choose Tottenville for its mix of character, walkability, and access to the rest of New York — with an average rent around $2,400 per month.
Expect strong transit options, a walkable street grid, and a steady supply of pre-war apartments, modern conversions, and the occasional new-development tower. OnePlace Rentals tracks live availability in Tottenville every day — including no-fee listings — so you only see what's actually rentable now.
Need help in another language?
Spanish · 中文 · Русский · বাংলা · العربية · Kreyòl · 한국어
Similar in Staten Island
You might also like.
Frequently asked
Tottenville rental FAQ.
- Are there no-fee apartments in Tottenville?
- Yes — OnePlace Rentals regularly lists no-fee apartments in Tottenville. Browse the No-Fee section on the Tottenville page or message us and we'll share the latest no-fee options.
- What is the average rent in Tottenville?
- The average rent in Tottenville is approximately $2,400 per month. Actual prices depend on size, building, and time of year.
- Can I schedule a showing with OnePlace?
- Yes. Text, WhatsApp, email, or schedule a call and a licensed agent will set up showings in Tottenville — usually within the day.
- Does OnePlace offer help in other languages?
- OnePlace Rentals supports renters in English, Spanish, Chinese, Bengali, Haitian Creole, Russian, Arabic, and Korean.
Want to live in Tottenville?
Tell us what you're looking for and a local rental expert will help — usually within an hour.